BooksOfTheMoon

The Unpleasantness at the Bellona Club (Lord Peter Wimsey, #5)

By Dorothy L. Sayers

Rating: 4 stars

I had intended to read the Wimsey series in order this time round, but I must have misread something, since I went straight from Whose Body? to this. I’ll go back and read the others before continuing, but I don’t feel I missed out. Something that I’ve really come to appreciate in these books is the treatment of the Great War and the experiences of those who fought, especially the frank discussion of the PTSD that many soldiers suffered. There’s also an interesting generational gap between those who fought and those who were too old to. It’s not quite boomers vs millennials, but the obvious lack of understanding of some in the older generation regarding what their children suffered makes for startling reading.

And through all this, Lord Peter Wimsey walks, with his mask firmly on, using an act of mild stupidity and geniality to try to forget about and move on from that past. This time, he’s got a dead body in his club and it turns out that finding out just when it became a dead body is very important. A throwaway line about the dead man has stayed with me: he was an old man, someone for whom “the war” meant the Crimean war, not even the Boer war never mind the Great War. I don’t quite know why that line resonates with me, but it really does.

Despite some dated language, the book feels very fresh. Despite being a world apart, it doesn’t feel nearly a century old by any means, and I blitzed through it. My Queen of Crime has always been Christie, but Sayers is pushing in deep on her flank.

Book details

Publisher: Public Domain
Year of publication: 2009

What Is Love?

By Jen Comfort

Rating: 4 stars

Maxine just about finished high school and, between ADHD and having to look after her younger sister, never even thought about college. Teddy is her polar opposite: a buttoned-up academic, born for the ivory tower. Maxine ends Teddy’s winning streak on Answers!, and goes on to her own. But in a special edition of the show, they’re both put up against the never-defeated champion Hercules McKnight, and have to team up to shore up each other’s weaknesses.

I loved this delightful enemies-to-lovers romance about rivals in a Jeopardy-style trivia quiz show. It’s got a sympathetic portrayal of ADHD and the problems that someone with that can have in a mass-education system (especially girls, who don’t necessarily present the same as boys).

I did wonder a bit about Teddy, who is supposed to be an academic, but doesn’t seem to do any teaching, or, indeed, any research. He’s presented initially as this very stuffy, privileged academic type, but we start to care for him as much as Maxine pretty quickly (and the scene when Maxine comes to his parents’ house for dinner is sweet and heartbreaking at the same time).

I do wish we’d got more of the relationship between Maxine and her younger sister, Olive, who she basically had to parent; and the relationship with fellow contestant Tarrah, with whom it seemed that Maxine seemed to have a tentative friendship, but there’s only so many pages, and it’s the Maxine-Teddy relationship that was the core of the book.

There’s some drama at the end with returning trivia legend McKnight, but, to be honest, it wasn’t overly dramatic. McKnight is portrayed throughout as an elitist, privileged snob with a whiff of corruption about him, and when it all hits the fan, it’s not entirely surprising. The actual end to the trivia contest had me cackling though.

There’s a tonne of trivia sprinkled throughout, including in question style at the start of each chapter. I’m no trivia master, but I’m pleased enough with how I did in those. Oh, and I loved the throwaway reference to the old story about Gandhi’s fondness for nukes in Civilization.

The book is pretty steamy, and I loved the trivia. Comfort got the spark between the two protagonists down perfectly. A lot of fun.

Book details

ISBN: 9781662516436

The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher: Or the Murder at Road Hill House

By Kate Summerscale

Rating: 2 stars

I picked up this book from a box of free books mostly because I wasn’t paying attention and thought it was a Victorian whodunnit. When I discovered my mistake, the book sat unread on my shelf for a very long time, because I’m really not a fan of true crime. I don’t like the idea of a real person’s pain and suffering being turned into entertainment. But I decided to give it a go anyway, and I’m honestly still not sure what to make of this book.

The tone is, by turns, sensational and puritanical. In one breath promising to unveil sordid secrets from within the sacred family home – it was, after all, during the Victorian era that the idea of the Englishman’s home being his castle was at its fullest extend – and on the other, clutching its metaphorical pearls at the idea that a child in the depths of poverty might go to such lengths as to steal something that could be turned into food. Those secrets behind closed doors, by the way, turned out to be nothing more interesting than infidelity, with the master of the house having an affair with the governess, who he would go on to marry.

The book also wants to be a history of the early police detective force. I don’t really think it succeeds in this either. It doesn’t really go into much detail on the history behind the force, although it does go into (sometimes excruciating) detail on early cases that the new force was involved with. The tone is relentlessly pro-police, without much critical eye on their flaws (there’s a brief mention of a major corruption scandal later on, but this is hurriedly passed over, and instead we’re asked to sympathise with the inspector who headed the force at this time).

I don’t really know who the book is for. The murder itself is sensationalised but then the tone switches to dry day by day account drawn from the historical record, before switching by to a more sensational tone later in the book; the police history is potted at best, and the relentlessly positive spin put on all the police actions is wearing, at best. If you want to read about this particular murder, the Wikipedia article will save you time and money.

Book details

ISBN: 9780747596486
Publisher: Bloomsbury Publishing
Year of publication: 2009

Powered by WordPress